| All Winners \ 1911 \ 1912 \ 1913 \ 1914 \ 1922 \ 1923 \ 1924 \ 1925 \ 1926 \ 1927 \ 1928 \ 1929 \ 1931 \ 1932 \ 1933 \ 1934 \ 1935 \ 1936 \ 1937 \ 1938 \ 1939 \ 1940 \ 1941 \ 1942 \ 1943 \ 1944 \ 1945 \ 1946 \ 1947 \ 1948 \ 1949 \ 1950 \ 1951 \ 1952 \ 1953 \ 1954 \ 1955 \ 1956 \ 1957 \ 1958 \ 1959 \ 1960 \ 1961 \ 1962 \ 1963 \ 1964 \ 1965 \ 1966 \ 1967 \ 1968 \ 1969 \ 1970 \ 1971 \ 1972 \ 1973 \ 1974 \ 1975 \ 1976 \ 1977 \ 1978 \ 1979 \ 1980 \ 1981 \ 1982 \ 1983 \ 1984 \ 1985 \ 1986 \ 1987 \ 1988 \ 1989 \ 1990 \ 1991 \ 1992 \ 1993 \ 1994 \ 1995 \ 1996 \ 1997 \ 1998 \ 1999 \ 2000 \ 2001 \ 2002 \ 2003 \ 2004 \ 2005 \ 2006 \ 2007 \ 2008 |
National League[]
| Player | Team | Votes |
| Barry Larkin | Cincinnati Reds | 281 points (11 1st-place votes) |
| Dante Bichette | Colorado Rockies | 251 points (6 1st-place votes) |
| Greg Maddux | Atlanta Braves | 249 points (7 1st-place votes) |
| Mike Piazza | Los Angeles Dodgers | 214 points (3 1st-place votes) |
| Eric Karros | Los Angeles Dodgers | 135 points |
| Reggie Sanders | Cincinnati Reds | 120 points |
| Larry Walker | Colorado Rockies | 88 points |
| Sammy Sosa | Chicago Cubs | 81 points |
| Tony Gwynn | San Diego Padres | 72 points |
| Craig Biggio | Houston Astros | 58 points |
| Ron Gant | Cincinnati Reds | 31 points (1 1st-place vote) |
| Barry Bonds | San Francisco Giants | 21 points |
| Mark Grace | Chicago Cubs | 14 points |
| Derek Bell | Houston Astros | 12 points |
| Jeff Bagwell | Houston Astros | 5 points |
| Andres Galarraga | Colorado Rockies | 4 points |
| Charlie Hayes | Philadelphia Phillies | 4 points |
| Vinny Castilla | Colorado Rockies | 3 points |
| Chipper Jones | Atlanta Braves | 3 points |
| Fred McGriff | Atlanta Braves | 2 points |
| Pete Schourek | Cincinnati Reds | 2 points |
| Jeff Conine | Florida Marlins | 1 point |
| Tom Henke | St. Louis Cardinals | 1 point |
American League[]
| Player | Team | Votes |
| Mo Vaughn | Boston Red Sox | 308 points (12 1st-place votes) |
| Albert Belle | Cleveland Indians | 300 points (11 1st-place votes) |
| Edgar Martinez | Seattle Mariners | 244 points (4 1st-place votes) |
| Jose Mesa | Cleveland Indians | 130 points (1 1st-place vote) |
| Jay Buhner | Seattle Mariners | 120 points |
| Randy Johnson | Seattle Mariners | 111 points |
| Tim Salmon | California Angels | 110 points |
| Frank Thomas | Chicago White Sox | 86 points |
| John Valentin | Boston Red Sox | 57 points |
| Gary Gaetti | Kansas City Royals | 45 points |
| Rafael Palmeiro | Baltimore Orioles | 34 points |
| Manny Ramirez | Cleveland Indians | 30 points |
| Tim Wakefield | Boston Red Sox | 20 points |
| Jim Edmonds | California Angels | 18 points |
| Paul O'Neill | New York Yankees | 14 points |
| Mark McGwire | Oakland Athletics | 7 points |
| Wade Boggs | New York Yankees | 5 points |
| Chuck Knoblauch | Minnesota Twins | 5 points |
| Gary DiSarcina | California Angels | 3 points |
| Cal Ripken | Baltimore Orioles | 3 points |
| Kirby Puckett | Minnesota Twins | 2 points |