Talk:MLB Thinks Gooden is in the Hall/@comment-24.90.128.73-20060406201122

Gooden was my favorite player growing up, but any talk of him making the HOF or comparing him to Koufax is just idle chatter meant to provoke. His lifetime ERA+ was 110 vs. Koufax&quot;s 131. You&quot;re basically making a case for Jamie Moyer being in the Hall (career 107 ERA+).

You want to talk about a borderline HOF former Met (and Yankee), discuss David Cone. 194 career wins probably won&quot;t do it, but he had eight absolutely dominating years from &quot;92 through &quot;99, was part of a World Series winner and has a Cy Young to his credit. He&quot;s a much better candidate than Doctor K.