Talk:Steroids...Who should be in the Hall of Fame?/@comment-69.249.64.157-20060326115308

I would vote in mcguire and bonds. However, I would not vote them in on the first ballot. This were hall of fame players even before the juice and would have gotten in anyway.

No vote for Sosa though because I beleive he was not going to be anywhere close to the Hall without his steroided numbers.

I would not vote-in palmeiro because he was not a dominant player in his era. He was very good, but I don&quot;t beleive &quot;consistantly good&quot; is good enough to make the Hall. The Hall should be reserved for all-time great dominant players.

Canseco on the other hand was dominant, but not for long and he was a complete Roid Head.

No vote for schilling either. He was only dominant for about 5 years and hasn&quot;t accumulated huge numbers over the span of his career.