Talk:Who's better, Peyton Manning or Tom Brady?/@comment-101784-20060310111429

This is exactly how this debate has gone every time it has been brought up. I don&quot;t think it is a simple answer. Afew simple things to begin with though. In terms of talent, there is no doubt that Peyton Manning is at least 10 times more talented than Tom Brady. The guy asked what would Brady do with Marvin harrison and I think the answer is nothing. I don&quot;t think Tom Brady accomplishes much on most other teams. It is clear to me that Tom Brady can&quot;t do all the things that Peyton Manning can do. Peyton Manning can do all the things that Tom Brady can do...except win. Peyton Manning for all his talent has been a loser throughout his career. Both in college and in the pros he has failed to win the big game. But that brings up another question. How much of winning and losing is the QB. Vinitiari made his FGs and Vanderjet missed his. How does that make Brady a winner and Manning a loser? An obscure rule won the Pats a SB and an undefeated team saw its coaches son kill himself right before the playoffs. How does that make a QB a winner or a loser?