Eli Manning.... Future great or one Manning too late??

by user 24.71.199.70

Now I know that Eli has only played for a year and a half and most QB's get a pass up until this point in their careers... but this has to be the year for Eli right??

Last season he made one huge play (on the comeback against the Broncos) and I am the first to admit it was Awsome! Considering all the luck they had last year (read the post "Did the Giants really win a game last year for more explanation") and considering that Tiki Barber was AMAZING last year, how good (or how bad) is Eli?

I am very skeptical about Young Eli. With the exception of Vick, Harrington and Boller Eli had the lowest passer rating of any of the starting QB's last year. Vick shouldn't be a QB, you all know about Harrington, and Boller was gibbled for most of last season plus he plays for the Ravens who rarely throw the ball. Also consider that Eli had Tiki, Shockey and Plax to throw to.

Eli certainly needs to have a really good this year, or he will get thrown to the Sharks. I do not think he has the stones and has survived because of his teammates.

Your thoughts??

Date
Wed 03/08/06, 7:22 pm EST