Talk:Who's better, Peyton Manning or Tom Brady?/@comment-101807-20060310152518

I always think of it like this: Would the Pats have won three Super Bowls w/Peyton Manning instead of Tom Brady? Would Tom Brady have won three Super Bowls with the Colts? The first one is tough -because Manning has a knack for crapping the cot when it matters most. But I think even the biggest Brady supporter has to admit that he would have less jewelry had he been starting for Jim Mora and Tony D these last five years. Does that mean Manning&quot;s better? I guess it should mean that. But when I think about it, it still comes down to results, and Manning&quot;s consistent failure at the most crucial times makes me believe that the Pats wouldn&quot;t have won those three Super Bowls w/Cut That Meat under center. So I&quot;m back where I started. Manning-Brady is basically the current equivalent of Marino-Montana. One clearly has superior tools, but couldn&quot;t/can&quot;t win, while the other&quot;s greatest skills appear to be leadership and courage under fire. Which matters more? In the end, it has to be the latter, because that&quot;s what it takes to win at the highest level, and winning, ultimately, IS the only thing.